
Sometimes, you think you’re making one thing, and you actually end up making quite another. Mistakes are responsible for classic foods like chocolate chip cookies, cheese, and potato chips. And that’s kind of what happened with this sauce. See, I love, love, love shrimp cocktail. And when I saw a variation for a Caribbean-style cocktail sauce in the Cook’s Illustrated Cookbook, I knew I’d found something special.


And it turns out, I had found something special. And it even passes for a cocktail sauce, kind of (but if I’m being honest, not really). But this baby’s real strength is as a dip for chips. It’s not as substantial as salsa or guacamole. But it packs such a flavor punch that even a little bit goes a long way.

Brown sugar tames the spice of jalapeno, and the bright, sour-yet-sweet flavor of freshly juiced limes shines through. Garlic and ginger are at their finest, playing backup among other strong flavors, rounding out the sauce, bringing it all together.

This sauce would also be great served over chicken or freshly grilled meat, or mixed into rice. It would add a fresh and unique kick to tacos if you drizzled it over the top. And it is great with shrimp (especially if you put a shrimp on a tortilla chip and dip the whole thing). It’s not shrimp cocktail, but whatever it is, it’s a great recipe for that.







